“Mothers’ Instinct” is a 1960s suburban psychodrama starring Anne Hathaway and Jessica Chastain as model homemakers whose friendship is tested by tragedy. The film, directed by Benoît Delhomme, struggles to find a consistent tone, veering between silliness and seriousness without fully committing to either. Delhomme, a gifted cinematographer, provides a visually striking backdrop but fails to create a cohesive atmosphere. The story, adapted from a Belgian thriller, follows the escalating battle between the two women as they grapple with grief, guilt, and paranoia.
The differences between the characters of Céline (Hathaway) and Alice (Chastain) are subtly revealed through their parenting styles and personal histories. After a terrible accident claims the life of Céline’s son Max, the women drift apart as blame and doubt fester. Céline’s attempts to bond with Alice’s son Theo are met with suspicion and protectiveness, leading to a series of mind games and power struggles. As the plot spirals into absurdity, it becomes difficult to discern victim from villain, stirring a sense of cool fascination and dark humor.
Both actresses deliver powerful performances, with Hathaway embodying a black widow-like elegance and Chastain portraying a woman pushed to the brink of sanity. Delhomme’s direction is meticulous but lacks the emotional depth and consistency needed to elevate the film to greatness. The narrative unfolds in a haze of pastel colors and sharp shadows, mirroring the internal turmoil of the characters. As the tension mounts and the story reaches a fever pitch, the audience is left waiting for a resolution that never quite arrives.
Despite its flaws, “Mothers’ Instinct” is a compelling exploration of female friendship, grief, and deception. The film delves into the complexities of motherhood and the dark impulses that can arise from loss and longing. Hathaway and Chastain’s nuanced portrayals breathe life into the flawed characters, drawing the audience into their twisted world. As the drama unfolds and the stakes are raised, the audience is left on edge, unsure of who to believe and where the story will ultimately lead.
In the end, “Mothers’ Instinct” is a flawed yet intriguing film that falls short of its ambitious goals. The clash of styles and tones, while engaging, ultimately detracts from the overall impact of the story. Delhomme’s visual flair and the actresses’ commitment to their roles elevate the material, but the film struggles to find a cohesive identity. Despite these drawbacks, “Mothers’ Instinct” remains a tantalizing watch, offering a glimpse into the darker side of suburban life and the complexities of female relationships. Hopefully, future projects will allow the talented cast and crew to fully realize their potential and deliver a more cohesive and impactful narrative.
